You Don’t Need to Play Nice. You Need to Lead Wisely

You Don’t Need to Play Nice. You Need to Lead Wisely

June 26, 20254 min read

Too many smart, capable leaders have been taught—explicitly or implicitly—that leadership requires smoothing edges, making others comfortable, and keeping the peace.

That playing nice—or even playing dead—is the safest path to influence. But in trying not to rock the boat, they end up silencing their own wisdom and authority.

And on the flip side, others have been taught that leadership means making noise, shaking things up, and proving a point—often by disrupting or destabilising what's already working. Sometimes it looks like bold action; other times its relentless politicking and power play. It’s the belief that impact requires intensity, and that discomfort is the only marker of change. But provocation without purpose rarely lands well—and can do just as much damage as avoidance.

I’ve been there. I’ve tried both ends of the spectrum—shrinking to keep the peace and pushing to be heard. Neither felt aligned. Neither delivered the kind of impact I knew I was capable of. It took me years to realise that wisdom sits in the middle. And once I found it, everything changed.

True leadership doesn’t perform. It discerns.

It takes more discernment to pause than to push. More courage to question quietly than to comply performatively. And more wisdom to hold your centre when the room gets loud, political or performative.

For high-performing leaders—especially in the Boardroom—authenticity isn’t soft. It’s your sharpest instrument of influence. When you are grounded in who you are, you become harder to manipulate, harder to rattle, and harder to ignore. And that is the energy that changes conversations, shifts dynamics, and elevates governance.

But let’s not pretend it’s easy. Leading authentically in rooms filled with legacy power structures, fragile egos, or masked agendas takes serious inner clarity. The tension between speaking truth and being strategic is real. The risk of being misunderstood—or deliberately sidelined—is also real.

You might be the most qualified person in the room and still feel the pressure to dilute your voice. You might second-guess yourself, wondering if what you’re seeing is really happening, or if you're overreacting. You might even tell yourself it’s better to wait, to soften, or to keep the peace—especially if you’ve learned the cost of being the truth-teller.

But here’s what I know: your voice, when used with wisdom and precision, is the governance tool that can shift entire systems. It doesn’t need to be loud. It needs to be clear.

And clarity is magnetic.

So how do you lead with authenticity in the Boardroom—without self-sacrificing or shape-shifting?

Here are five small anchors that can change everything:

  • Ground yourself before you speak. Ask: “Am I speaking from my role, my values, or my ego?”

  • Get clear on your ‘non-negotiables’. What are you no longer willing to bypass for comfort or cohesion?

  • Name dynamics without naming names. Use neutral, systemic language to raise behavioural concerns without personalising the issue.

  • Call yourself forward first. Model the tone and accountability you want to see, especially when conversations get political.

  • Build relationships before you need them. Authentic leadership is amplified when trust is already in the room.

Many leaders are starting to realise something important:

It’s not just about knowing the right governance frameworks or behaviours — it’s about living them. And that kind of leadership doesn’t grow in a vacuum. It needs reflection, support, and the right circle around you.

More and more seasoned leaders are quietly admitting:

“I know how to lead... but I’m not always sure how to lead this way.”

The way that’s courageous but not reckless.

Discerning, not performative.

Accountable, not over-functioning.

That’s exactly why I built our --

Strategic Peer Environments

They’re not just here to talk governance — they are bespoke, carefully curated spaces created to support you in living it. Environments where you don’t have to explain the weight you carry or filter the truth of your experience. Where wisdom, not noise, sets the tone.

These environments are intentionally designed as confidential, high-trust spaces where experienced leaders can engage in real, raw, and reflective dialogue.

This is not professional development in the traditional sense.

It’s a held container for truth-telling, pattern-breaking, and recalibrating — the kind that’s required to lead governance that actually works — for people, performance, and purpose.

Because real transformation doesn’t happen through information alone.

It happens through repetition, reflection, and reinforcement.

And these sessions create space for all three — with peers who get it. Who’ve walked into rooms like yours. Who’ve had to navigate complexity, perform under pressure, and still hold integrity in their leadership.

In a small, safe, perfectly formed circle, you’re not just learning behavioural governance —

You’re practising it. You’re embodying it.

You’re shaping it into something real, sustainable, and powerful that you can draw on — not just in the Boardroom, but in every forum, decision, and leadership moment across your career.

If this speaks to something in you—if you feel the quiet call to lead more wisely, more fully, and more authentically—we’d love to hear from you. Let’s explore whether one of these environments might support your next chapter.

Book a time with me here:

Strategic Peer Environment Alignment Call

to start the conversation. No pressure. Just an open space to connect and see what’s possible.

I’d love to see you there!

Founder and Managing Director of The Governance Collective Pty Ltd. Australia’s leading corporate governance organisation with a fresh approach.

Lisa Coletta

Founder and Managing Director of The Governance Collective Pty Ltd. Australia’s leading corporate governance organisation with a fresh approach.

Back to Blog